UP Police Regs 133Chapter 11 · Research
Section 133 · Paragraph 128. Action on the widespread theft of goods from railway goods trains
Text size — level 1 of 4
In any area where incidents of theft of goods from goods trains are widespread, the Superintendent of Government Railway Police should inform the Superintendent of Police of the concerned district, and concerted measures will then be taken.
Note
(1) Not obtaining signatures of witnesses on statements - Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure prohibits the absence of signatures of witnesses when their statements are recorded under subsection (3) of Section 161.
However, obtaining the signatures of witnesses on their statements will not render them insignificant, although the degree of caution required in using them will be increased. 2. The court cannot refuse to supply copies of the statements of the accused on the ground that they bear the signatures of witnesses.
(2) Search within the jurisdiction of another police station - If there is a suspicion that evidence will be concealed or destroyed due to delay in obtaining a warrant, a police officer of one police station may conduct a search within the jurisdiction of another police station without obtaining a warrant from the officer in charge of that station.
(3) Recording of Reasons - When an officer conducts a search without a warrant under Section 165 or 166, he must record in writing the reasons for his belief. If the reasons are not recorded, the search will be illegal.
Where a search was conducted under Section 165 without recording the reasons, the Patna and Lahore High Courts held it to be malafide.
(4) Who may conduct a search - Section 165 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1903, provides that the officer in charge of a police station or the investigating officer of a case may also conduct a search. If such an officer wishes to have another subordinate officer conduct a search, he must issue a written order to his subordinate, stating the reasons for the search, and specifying the place to be searched and the object to be searched. The person authorized to conduct the search will be authorized to search only that place and the object specified in the written order. When an Assistant Sub-Inspector is in charge of a police station and has written the First Information Report, he may take action under this section, empowered to investigate the crime.
An officer cannot give a verbal order or authorization to a subordinate to conduct a search. If a person enters a house without a verbal order, he is guilty of trespassing and is liable to compensate for any damages caused by the search. A person conducting a search without a written order may be prevented from doing so, and a group of people who prevent such an illegal search will not be liable for rioting or obstructing a public servant in the discharge of their duties.
Self-search does not necessarily mean that the officer himself opens boxes, digs up floors, etc.; it simply means that the entire process is conducted under his general supervision. (13 Criminal Law General 763). In a case where two houses were to be searched simultaneously, one by the officer in charge of the police station and the other by the head constable, it was held that, in the absence of a failure of justice, the second search cannot be considered so routine that the High Court should intervene through review.
(5) Witnesses must be independent and reputable persons - According to subsection (4) of Section 100 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, two or more witnesses called for the presence of a search must be independent and reputable persons. Independent witnesses mean that they must be free from police influence. If the same witnesses have been present during multiple police raids, they cannot be considered independent. A search conducted in the presence of witnesses who are themselves involved in criminal cases, live near the police station, and are members of a political party opposing the accused would be suspect.
If there are no witnesses other than the police, nor can it be proven that independent witnesses were unavailable, the seizure cannot be considered reliable. The Inspector of the Anti-Corruption Department should make serious efforts to obtain the testimony of independent witnesses for the search at the time of the raid. In a case where a trap was laid to catch a bribe taken by a public servant, but the witnesses to the raid and the seizure of money were interested, their testimony was not considered reliable. Where the police did not even try to obtain such reputable witnesses.
(6) When should identification be conducted? - In the case of a person, identification should be conducted as soon as possible after his arrest and in the case of an animal or object, after its recovery. There are two reasons why identification should not be delayed:
First, the sooner identification occurs after the incident, the fresher the witnesses' memories will be, making it easier to correctly identify them.
Second, delay raises doubts about whether the arrested person or recovered items have been shown to the witnesses or whether they have had the opportunity to see them.
It is noteworthy that if circumstances raise doubts during the trial, the entire identification process will be rendered unreliable and futile.
Where identification was conducted two months after the incident, it was not considered satisfactory.
It is desirable that identification proceedings be completed as soon as possible after arrest and before release on bail.
(7) Identification of Persons - The question of identification of persons arises only when the witness is unfamiliar to them. If the witness already knows the accused, the identification process will be meaningless. Successful identification requires that the person identified possess a distinctive feature that makes identification possible, and that the witness have had a reasonable opportunity to see the accused clearly. The identification of a person who was unidentified 15 months after the incident and was unknown to the witness was considered unreliable. The witness had only seen a glimpse of the accused fleeing on a moonlit night.
Identification of an accused by voice was considered reliable evidence.
Distinctive marks that can be described verbally should be obscured by lines on paper so that witnesses trained by the police cannot use them as the basis for their identification. However, faint or commonly found marks need not be obscured by slips of paper.
Neither so few marks should be concealed that they would adversely affect the accused, nor so many marks that an honest witness would be confused.
(8) Final Report in a Case to Be Proven There are situations when, after investigation, a case is not proven and it is just and expedient to close it. In such a situation, the police officer submits a corresponding final report to the magistrate. Upon receiving such a report, the magistrate may order further investigation, but cannot order the filing of a charge sheet (challan) against the accused.
There is also a view that the magistrate cannot order further investigation. If the magistrate disagrees with the police report, he can take cognizance himself and proceed with the trial.
If the investigator is not satisfied with the evidence collected, the police prosecutor cannot request the magistrate to order the summoning of the accused unless additional evidence is available.
Any failure to attach the process records to the challan would be a mere irregularity that can be rectified. If the investigation has not been completed, the report submitted before that cannot be considered a police report for the purposes of Section 173(2).
A person's reputation does not necessarily mean that he or she is wealthy, has social standing, or has property. A person who is not guilty of reprehensible conduct will be considered respectable. A person will not become disreputable simply because he or she has previously given evidence to the police.
Even a person belonging to a lower caste will be considered respectable if the occupant of the house can trust him or her.
The witnesses called for the search should not be associated with the government or government officials.
Note
(1) Not obtaining signatures of witnesses on statements - Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure prohibits the absence of signatures of witnesses when their statements are recorded under subsection (3) of Section 161.
However, obtaining the signatures of witnesses on their statements will not render them insignificant, although the degree of caution required in using them will be increased. 2. The court cannot refuse to supply copies of the statements of the accused on the ground that they bear the signatures of witnesses.
(2) Search within the jurisdiction of another police station - If there is a suspicion that evidence will be concealed or destroyed due to delay in obtaining a warrant, a police officer of one police station may conduct a search within the jurisdiction of another police station without obtaining a warrant from the officer in charge of that station.
(3) Recording of Reasons - When an officer conducts a search without a warrant under Section 165 or 166, he must record in writing the reasons for his belief. If the reasons are not recorded, the search will be illegal.
Where a search was conducted under Section 165 without recording the reasons, the Patna and Lahore High Courts held it to be malafide.
(4) Who may conduct a search - Section 165 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1903, provides that the officer in charge of a police station or the investigating officer of a case may also conduct a search. If such an officer wishes to have another subordinate officer conduct a search, he must issue a written order to his subordinate, stating the reasons for the search, and specifying the place to be searched and the object to be searched. The person authorized to conduct the search will be authorized to search only that place and the object specified in the written order. When an Assistant Sub-Inspector is in charge of a police station and has written the First Information Report, he may take action under this section, empowered to investigate the crime.
An officer cannot give a verbal order or authorization to a subordinate to conduct a search. If a person enters a house without a verbal order, he is guilty of trespassing and is liable to compensate for any damages caused by the search. A person conducting a search without a written order may be prevented from doing so, and a group of people who prevent such an illegal search will not be liable for rioting or obstructing a public servant in the discharge of their duties.
Self-search does not necessarily mean that the officer himself opens boxes, digs up floors, etc.; it simply means that the entire process is conducted under his general supervision. (13 Criminal Law General 763). In a case where two houses were to be searched simultaneously, one by the officer in charge of the police station and the other by the head constable, it was held that, in the absence of a failure of justice, the second search cannot be considered so routine that the High Court should intervene through review.
(5) Witnesses must be independent and reputable persons - According to subsection (4) of Section 100 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, two or more witnesses called for the presence of a search must be independent and reputable persons. Independent witnesses mean that they must be free from police influence. If the same witnesses have been present during multiple police raids, they cannot be considered independent. A search conducted in the presence of witnesses who are themselves involved in criminal cases, live near the police station, and are members of a political party opposing the accused would be suspect.
If there are no witnesses other than the police, nor can it be proven that independent witnesses were unavailable, the seizure cannot be considered reliable. The Inspector of the Anti-Corruption Department should make serious efforts to obtain the testimony of independent witnesses for the search at the time of the raid. In a case where a trap was laid to catch a bribe taken by a public servant, but the witnesses to the raid and the seizure of money were interested, their testimony was not considered reliable. Where the police did not even try to obtain such reputable witnesses.
(6) When should identification be conducted? - In the case of a person, identification should be conducted as soon as possible after his arrest and in the case of an animal or object, after its recovery. There are two reasons why identification should not be delayed:
First, the sooner identification occurs after the incident, the fresher the witnesses' memories will be, making it easier to correctly identify them.
Second, delay raises doubts about whether the arrested person or recovered items have been shown to the witnesses or whether they have had the opportunity to see them.
It is noteworthy that if circumstances raise doubts during the trial, the entire identification process will be rendered unreliable and futile.
Where identification was conducted two months after the incident, it was not considered satisfactory.
It is desirable that identification proceedings be completed as soon as possible after arrest and before release on bail.
(7) Identification of Persons - The question of identification of persons arises only when the witness is unfamiliar to them. If the witness already knows the accused, the identification process will be meaningless. Successful identification requires that the person identified possess a distinctive feature that makes identification possible, and that the witness have had a reasonable opportunity to see the accused clearly. The identification of a person who was unidentified 15 months after the incident and was unknown to the witness was considered unreliable. The witness had only seen a glimpse of the accused fleeing on a moonlit night.
Identification of an accused by voice was considered reliable evidence.
Distinctive marks that can be described verbally should be obscured by lines on paper so that witnesses trained by the police cannot use them as the basis for their identification. However, faint or commonly found marks need not be obscured by slips of paper.
Neither so few marks should be concealed that they would adversely affect the accused, nor so many marks that an honest witness would be confused.
(8) Final Report in a Case to Be Proven There are situations when, after investigation, a case is not proven and it is just and expedient to close it. In such a situation, the police officer submits a corresponding final report to the magistrate. Upon receiving such a report, the magistrate may order further investigation, but cannot order the filing of a charge sheet (challan) against the accused.
There is also a view that the magistrate cannot order further investigation. If the magistrate disagrees with the police report, he can take cognizance himself and proceed with the trial.
If the investigator is not satisfied with the evidence collected, the police prosecutor cannot request the magistrate to order the summoning of the accused unless additional evidence is available.
Any failure to attach the process records to the challan would be a mere irregularity that can be rectified. If the investigation has not been completed, the report submitted before that cannot be considered a police report for the purposes of Section 173(2).
A person's reputation does not necessarily mean that he or she is wealthy, has social standing, or has property. A person who is not guilty of reprehensible conduct will be considered respectable. A person will not become disreputable simply because he or she has previously given evidence to the police.
Even a person belonging to a lower caste will be considered respectable if the occupant of the house can trust him or her.
The witnesses called for the search should not be associated with the government or government officials.
Your private note on this section
Only you can see this note.

